No.240 / 280Nurture & survive · Fishing & catching

Gear-Gated Catches

Seeing a fish isn't enough; you need the right rod or net to land it.

Prototype complexity
Who plays
Solo decisions
Design focus
Progression · Planning · Spatial
DREDGENo.240DREDGE

01The core loop

Action → feedback → next choice
  1. 01Find a new spot
  2. 02Learn your gear can't reach it
  3. 03Upgrade or swap gear
  4. 04Return and catch it

↻Feedback changes the situation — the next round starts from there.

Walk through one round

A simplified design example. Situations and numbers illustrate the mechanic, not exact rules from a reference game.

  1. T1

    Turn 1 · The situation

    The boat fits 2 gear pieces: coastal and shallow rods; a deep-water spot appears ahead.

  2. T2

    Turn 2 · The player chooses

    They return to port and swap the shallow rod for a deep one.

  3. T3

    Turn 3 · The feedback

    The deep spot opens, the first cast lands a valuable fish, though shallow spots get skipped.

  4. T4

    Turn 4 · The next decision

    The player starts saving to expand the hull's equipment slots.

How it plays

Different fish or waters require specific gear types, such as deep, shallow or trawl equipment. Gear often occupies limited boat or pack slots, so players choose what to bring. Gear progression pulls players into farther, riskier waters.

What the player weighs

  • Pack many tools for coverage vs. keep room for the catch
  • Invest in deep gear vs. upgrade engines for range

02Start small

Quest · 0/3Prototype complexityCompact prototypeWho plays · Solo decisions

Scope is an editorial estimate for the minimum prototype, not the reference game or a production schedule.

03One mechanic, different implementations

DREDGE
D

DREDGE

P1

Spots are typed (coastal, oceanic, shallow, abyssal and so on), each requiring matching equipment, and gear takes grid space on the boat that competes with cargo.

Graveyard Keeper
G

Graveyard Keeper

P2

Fishing requires obtaining and upgrading a rod, with better rods presumably unlocking more species or quality; I'm not certain about the exact gating.

The difference worth noticing

DREDGE binds gear gates to spatial management; Graveyard Keeper's feel more like a classic tech-tree upgrade.

Case notes are Yoroll editorial summaries; rules may change between versions.

04What could you combine?

Fusion · Original design proposal · not an existing feature
Gear-Gated CatchesFishing & catching+

Give gear a point budget per trip: 10 points total, with a deep rod costing 6, forcing a choice between coverage and specialization.

Prototype this combo in Yoroll

→Follow the next idea

Fishing & catching

Where to Cast

Cast farther or more precisely and the same water yields different fish.

Prototype complexity
Who plays
Solo decisions
  1. 01Read the water's surface
  2. 02Charge for distance
  3. 03Landing spot sets the odds
  4. 04Adjust from the results
Stardew Valley · Dinkum
Fishing & catching

Fish Pond Farming

Stock a home pond with your catch and it breeds and produces over time.

Prototype complexity
Who plays
Solo decisions
  1. 01Stock a fish
  2. 02Wait for growth and yield
  3. 03Meet capacity requests
  4. 04Harvest, process, sell
Stardew Valley · Dinkum
Exploration & routes

Unlockable Fast-Travel Network

Each node you unlock makes the world a little smaller.

Prototype complexity
Who plays
Solo decisions
  1. 01Discover a node
  2. 02Activate or pay for it
  3. 03Travel between nodes
  4. 04Plan farther expeditions
Elden Ring · Hollow Knight
yorollGAMEPLAY ATLAS

Good mechanics deserve a closer look. Good ideas deserve a next step.

Entries are written by Yoroll editors. Game names and trademarks belong to their respective owners.